More than one-third of all Saudi-led air raids on Yemen
have hit civilian sites, such as school buildings, hospitals, markets,
mosques and economic infrastructure, according to the most comprehensive
survey of the conflict.
The findings, revealed by the Guardian
on Friday, contrast with claims by the Saudi government, backed by its
US and British allies, that Riyadh is seeking to minimise civilian
casualties.
The survey, conducted by the Yemen Data Project,
a group of academics, human rights organisers and activists, will add
to mounting pressure in the UK and the US on the Saudi-led coalition,
which is facing accusations of breaching international humanitarian law.
It will refocus attention on UK arms sales
to Saudi Arabia, worth more than £3.3bn since the air campaign began,
and the role of British military personnel attached to the Saudi command
and control centre, from which air operations are being mounted. Two
British parliamentary committees have called for the suspension of such sales until a credible and independent inquiry has been conducted.
Saudi Arabia
disputed the Yemen Data Project figures, describing them as “vastly
exaggerated”, and challenged the accuracy of the methodology, saying
somewhere such as a school building might have been a school a year ago,
but was now being used by rebel fighters.
The independent and non-partisan survey, based on open-source data,
including research on the ground, records more than 8,600 air attacks
between March 2015, when the Saudi-led campaign began, and the end of
August this year. Of these, 3,577 were listed as having hit military
sites and 3,158 struck non-military sites.
Where it could not be established whether a location attacked was
civilian or military, the strikes were classified as unknown, of which
there are 1,882 incidents.
Saudi Arabia intervened in March 2015 to support the Yemeni government against Iran-backed Houthi rebels
in control of the capital, Sana’a. The UN has put the death toll of the
18-month war at more than 10,000, with 3,799 of them being civilians.
Human rights organisations in Yemen have documented repeated
violations by the Houthis, including the use of landmines and
indiscriminate shelling. Human Rights Watch noted this year that Yemeni
civilians had “suffered serious laws of war violations by all sides.”
The Yemen Data Project has chosen to focus exclusively on the impact
of the air campaign, rather than fighting on the ground, citing the
difficulty of gaining access to frontline fighting and impartial
information.
One of the most problematic findings of the survey for Saudi Arabia
is the number of reported repeat attacks. While some attacks on civilian
sites can be explained away as mistakes or being the location of
military camps in densely populated areas such as Sana’a, repeated
strikes on school buildings and hospitals will add to demands for an
independent investigation.
One school building in Dhubab, Taiz governorate, has been hit nine
times, according to the data. A market in Sirwah, Marib governorate, has
been struck 24 times.
The UK’s shadow defence secretary, Clive Lewis, said of the survey:
“It’s sickening to think of British-built weapons being used against
civilians and the government has an absolute responsibility to do
everything in its power to stop that from happening. But as ministers
turn a blind eye to the conflict in Yemen, evidence that humanitarian
law has been violated is becoming harder to ignore by the day.”
The Liberal Democrat foreign affairs spokesperson, Tom Brake, said
the data added more weight to calls for the suspension of arms sales.
“Despite consistent evidence showing targeting of civilians, first
Cameron and now May’s governments have continued their hypocritical
defence of Saudi Arabia’s brutal campaign in Yemen,” he said.
Sixty-four members of the US Congress, from the Democratic and
Republican parties, sent a letter to Barack Obama last month urging the
president to postpone sales of new arms to Saudi Arabia. The US also provides the Saudis with intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance and logistical support.
The Democratic congressman Ted Lieu, who organised the letter and is a
colonel in the US air force reserve, said: “The actions of the
Saudi-led coalition in Yemen are as reprehensible as they are illegal.
The multiple, repeated airstrikes on civilians look like war crimes.”
Campaigners are calling for an independent inquiry to establish whether
attacks on civilian targets are because of poor intelligence, lack of
precision on the part of the Saudi-led coalition planes, or a high
degree of disregard for civilian lives.
Staff at the Yemen Data Project said they adopted rigorous standards,
using news reports aligned with both sides in the conflict and
crosschecked against other sources, such as social media,
non-governmental organisations and evidence on the ground.
According to the project, the Saudi-led coalition hit more
non-military sites than military in five of the past 18 months. In
October 2015, the figures were 291, compared with 208; in November, 126
against 34; December, 137 compared with 62; February 2016, 292 to 139,
and March, 122 compared with 80.
Over the course of the war, the survey lists 942 attacks on
residential areas, 114 on markets, 34 on mosques, 147 on school
buildings, 26 on universities and 378 on transport.
Asked by the Guardian about the figures during a visit to London, the
Saudi foreign minister, Adel bin Ahmed al-Jubeir, portrayed the Saudi
air force as professional and armed with precision weapons.
He said the Houthis had “turned schools and hospitals and mosques
into command and control centres. They have turned them into weapons
depots in a way that they are no longer civilian targets. They are
military targets. They might have been a school a year ago. But they
were not a school when they were bombed”.
The attachment of British military staff at the Saudi command centre has become increasingly controversial.
A UK Ministry of Defence spokesperson said: “The United Kingdom is
not a member of the Saudi-led coalition and UK personnel are not
involved in directing or conducting operations in Yemen, or in the
target selection process.
“The MoD does provide training and shares best practice to the Royal
Saudi air force, including training on targeting. We also provided
guidance and advice to support continued compliance with international
humanitarian law.”
The Yemen Data Project was set up this year in response to a lack of
reliable official military figures. It says the project brings together
figures from backgrounds in security, academia, human rights and
humanitarian issues, and describes it as “independently funded to avoid
any partisan affiliation.”
“Where independent reporting is not available, the data has been
cross-referenced with sources from opposing sides to the conflict to
ensure the reporting is as accurate and impartial as possible,” the
project said.
Given the general lack of transparency from parties to the conflict
and a paucity of independent reporting on the ground, the data had been
verified and cross-referenced to the greatest extent possible, it added.
The number of civilian casualties is not included, because much of
this area is highly politicised and it has not been possible to
independently verify claims.
He was crushed by a truck that was trying to force the picket line.
According to the workers, the truck driver was ordered to break the
picket line by the Chief of Staff at the plant.
A strike had been called against the company contracted to run the
plant, the SEAM. The company had fired 37 temporary workers, as well as a
group of workers organized with the USB base union, who were actively
leading struggles on the workplace. SEAM had previously agreed to
re-hire 13 of the workers, but it suddenly rejected the agreement.
Therefore, the workers immediately went on strike and blocked the exit
of trucks from the plant.
The workers testify that they heard the Chief of Staff shouting at
the truck driver “Go, go!” and the driver initially refusing; then,
after the Chief’s insistent order, he started driving in a narrow road
in the wrong direction, at high speed. Eldanf was hit, together with
other two workers, one of them injured. The police was guarding the
protest, but didn’t do anything.
Eldanf – 53 years old, father of five – was born in Egypt, where he
was a teacher. He had been working in the GLS plant for 14 years. He
wasn’t one of the fired workers, he had a permanent contract and was
also waiting for his Italian citizenship. He was there in solidarity
with his comrades.
The Piacenza Prosecutor’s office established that his death was a car
accident, since they deny that there was any strike or protest taking
place at that moment, although police was on site to manage “public
order”. The truck driver is not under arrest, nor, obviously, is the
Chief of Staff who ordered to crush the picket.
Many demonstrations took place in Italy during the day to mourn the
loss of Eldanf. The protesters occupied the railway in Piacenza, while
in Bologna a rally was attacked by the police while they were trying to
get inside the train station. Other demonstrations took place in Pavia,
in Naples and in other cities. The GLS plant in Piacenza in still
blocked. The FIOM union declared a solidarity strike at the Ferrari
plant.
Logistics is a sector that has constantly experienced strong
struggles in the past years, which were always repressed with extreme
violence both by police and by the companies themselves. This is
especially relevant to the area around Piacenza, which has experienced
such episodes in the past. The trucks have been constantly used as a
weapon against pickets, causing many injuries. Many had remarked that
the first victim of this killer practice was just a matter of time.
We, as Struggles in Italy, would like to express our condolences and
offer our solidarity to the family and comrades of Abdelssalam Eldanf.
Prime Minister Sherif Ismail has issued a decree banning
the construction and restoration of all statues, murals and sculptures
in public squares without prior authorization from both the Ministry of
Culture and the Ministry of Antiquities.
Wednesday's decision
comes in the wake of several unusual and poorly-crafted statues that
have reared their ugly heads across the country over the past couple of
years.
Most recently a statue in Sohag,
intended to represent a martyred soldier embracing his mother, was met
with criticism and anger last week as many considered it inappropriate,
and some even suggested that it appeared to be a portrayal of sexual
harassment. The incomplete statue has already undergone modifications.
One of the the most striking of these public artworks was an ill-conceived recreation of Queen Nefertiti’s head in the town of Samalout,
in the governorate of Minya (see image at top right), last year. The
ancient Egyptian queen is internationally remembered, among other
attributes, for her beautiful face and delicate features, but the
Samalout likeness failed to live up to this legacy, earning itself names
such as "Frankenstein."
So
provocative was this version of Queen Nefertiti that Samalout
authorities decided to tear it down in July 2015, after widespread
ridicule on social networking sites.
Another memorably lackluster statue is that of Colonel Ahmed Orabi
Pasha, leader of Egypt’s armed resistance movement (1879-82) against
British forces, erected in the Nile Delta Governorate of Sharqiya. Also
widely mocked, it depicts a green-painted likeness of Orabi riding a
cartoonish white horse, mounted on a multicolored concrete base.
Last month municipal authorities in the village of Hurriyet Razna, Orabi's birthplace, ordered that the whole statue be repainted.
Privately owned Youm7 news portal reports that
Sharqiya authorities may also impose penalties on those who distorted
the statue, and will move to beautify the public square in which it is
found so as “to restore its aesthetic appearance.”
Along the Cairo-Ismailia Desert Highway can be found a public
sculpture of a bronze male athlete flexing his biceps. It was recently
repainted brown, with white paint used just for his hair and swimsuit,
and the result, some say, looks like a statue of an aging man in white underpants.
Social
media filled with derision about the botched paint job, some calling the
statue "a giant in his underwear," while others suggested that it
should be featured in Egyptian underwear advertisements.
There was also the unusually colored statue of popular folk-inspired musician and composer Mohamed Abdel Wahab
in Bab al-Shareya, his birthplace. Its shiny brown suit and golden face
and hands were the subject of criticism early this year, to the extent
that it was reportedly repainted by
school students in February.
Critics were quick to point out that,
despite its makeover, the statue's face more closely resembles that of
the ousted President Hosni Mubarak than Abdel Wahab's.
The fiberglass statue was lightly damaged after falling off its base in January 2014, apparently after several banners tied around it neck led to the statue being blown down during strong winds.
Egypt has approved
the construction of 19 new prisons since January 2011 amid an ongoing
crackdown on freedoms, according to report released on Monday by the
Arabic Network for Human Rights Information (ANHRI.)
The number of prisons has risen in Egypt from
43 to 62 since 2011, when then-president Hosni Mubarak was ousted after a
popular uprising against his rule.
Out of the 19 new prisons, 16 were built during
the reign of Adli Mansour and Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, two under the rule
of Mohamed Mursi and one during the transitional period led by the
Supreme Council of the Armed Forces.
According to the report, prisons
across Egypt are bursting at the seams due to “random arrests and unjust
trials, in addition to the unfair laws passed after July 3, 2013,”
when then-Defence Minister Sisi ousted Mursi following mass protests
against the latter's rule.
Hundreds have been arrested for breaking the
controversial assembly law issued during the transitional months under
then-Interim President Mansour. The law imposes restrictions on protests
and stipulates that protesters must obtain a permit from the interior
ministry beforehand.
The report also ascribed the government’s need
for new prisons to the extension of pre-trial detention periods, which
should not exceed two years, according to the law.
Photojournalist Mahmoud Abu Zeid, widely known
as Shawkan, is among those who exceeded the legal maximum period in
pre-trial detention, having spent over two years in prison before he was
referred to court in December 2015.
There are no official statistics on the
interior ministry’s website regarding the number of inmates in Egyptian
prisons, but head of the Prison Authority Mostafa Baz said in a
televised interview in May 2016 that the number of prisoners stands at
80,000.
However, a source at the Prison Authority, who
preferred to remain anonymous, told ANHRI that Egyptian
prisoners totaled over 106,000 prisoners, 60,000 of whom are political
prisoners, despite security officials repeatedly asserting that Egyptian
prisons were free of political prisoners and detainees.
According to the report, the post-July 3
period, as well as the period of sectarian violence during the early
1990s, are the only periods during which the number of political
detainees exceeded that of criminal detainees in Egypt.
The report said that the Egyptian regime needs
to recognise the problems that arise from absence of law and
accountability policy, saying that “stability may come through
repression, or through justice and the rule of law, and the latter is
more lasting.”
“The government builds new prisons, detains
larger number of activists, at a time when the country suffers an
economic crisis and is reluctant to build hospitals, schools and public
libraries,” the report read.
Scores of microbus drivers began striking
in Cairo’s Maadi district early Monday morning in protest over the fatal
shooting of a fellow driver by police earlier in the day.
The strike left throngs of commuters stranded in several parts of Maadi, particularly Al-Arab and Street Seven neighborhoods.
A
driver participating in the strike, speaking on condition of anonymity,
told Mada Masr that the microbus driver was killed after a minor
collision with a police vehicle under a bridge on the ring road in
Maadi’s Saqr Qureish neighborhood. They quarreled, and then the officer
took out his weapon and shot the microbus driver in the head, his
colleague reported.
The Ministry of Interior presented a slightly different account of the event in a statement on Monday, asserting
that a member of the Basateen Police Station, who had been called to
resolve the quarrel, accidentally killed the driver. Upon arriving
at the scene, he reportedly responded by "firing a warning shot in the
air from the gun in his possession, which resulted in the accidental
death of the driver."
Another striking driver, also speaking on
condition of anonymity, identified the deceased driver as a 20-year-old
from Beni Suef, known by the nickname “Gamal Julia.” The Ministry of
Interior’s statement identified him as “Gamal,” with the initials
“N.T.” Other striking drivers stated that their deceased colleague had
been married for just under a month.
Despite the microbus strike,
taxis and public buses continued to operate on Monday, prompting several
drivers to form roadblocks to impede traffic. In some instances,
striking drivers threatened other drivers who were not taking part in
the collective action.
The fatality in Maadi is the latest in a
string of similar incidents in which police have killed unarmed
civilians in recent months.
Demonstrators took to the streets of Cairo’s Darb al-Ahmar in February, following the fatal shooting of a civilian by a police officer, leading to clashes between angry residents and police forces in the heavily populated district.
According to the Nadeem Center for the Rehabilitation of Victims of Violence of Violence and Torture’s July report, 40 people across the country have died as a result of police brutality this year.
In mid-August, President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi introduced amendments to provisions of the police authority law,
after Parliament approved the legislation earlier in the month. The
amendments impose greater restrictions on the police's use of force and
firearms in incidents which do not warrant such a response.
The
amendments also mandated that police personnel should not be in constant
possession of state-issued firearms, stipulating that they submit their
weapons to storage facilities designated by their presiding officers at
the conclusion of each shift, except in cases where a presiding officer
or authority judges that it is necessary to maintain possession.
Officials in the Upper Egyptian
governorate of Sohag are conducting investigations to identify those
involved in dumping the carcasses of 250 skinned donkeys disposed of on
a desert road near the town of Akhmim.
Local media outlets reported that investigations began on Monday, following the discovery of the donkeys the previous day. Graphic photos circulating on
social media revealed how the animals were dumped in the open, after
being slaughtered and skinned for their hides, which are increasingly
being marketed as cattle leather and sold at marked-up prices in
domestic markets.
The 250 carcasses were found in one
concentrated area along a small desert road near the village of Kola
without a safe or hygienic burial, in close proximity to agricultural
and residential areas.
Sohag Governor Ayman Abdel Moneim
has mobilized a team of veterinarians and environmental specialists
from the governorate to safely dispose of the decomposing bodies at a
safe distance away from any inhabited areas, reported the privately
owned Youm7 news portal.
The
veterinarians noted that the donkeys had not been slaughtered for their
meat, but had only been skinned for their hides, a recurring phenomenon
in Egypt.
Less than one month ago, three men in Old Cairo were jailed after being apprehended in a tannery with the carcasses of four donkeys. Another three donkeys were found alive in the tannery.
The
men reportedly confessed to selling the donkey hides for substantially
marked-up prices at local leather shops and tanneries, which market them
as being leather from cattle. Jailed pending investigations, they added
that they were not slaughtering or selling the donkeys for their meat.
An unnamed veterinarian from the Ministry of Agriculture told local media outlets
last month that the average price of an adult donkey may exceed LE200,
yet some farmers and vendors of donkeys – who have traditionally
supplied local zoos and circuses, to feed lions and tigers – are
currently demanding nearly 10 times that price per animal.
He
pointed out the sale of donkey hides is far more profitable than the
sale of their meat, particularly amid market indicators of a growing overseas demand for donkey hides. Among the countries with the largest demand for donkey hides is China, where they are increasingly used to manufacture gelatin, glue and medicines.