TIME
January 8, 2013
Jared Malsin
Ramadan Romih, the heavyset manager of the White House Net, an Internet
café up the street from the U.S. embassy in Cairo, sat on a chair on the
sidewalk outside his shop, smoking
a large tobacco water pipe. He hasn’t had many customers recently, he
says, because of the high concrete wall blocking the street next to his
shop. The wall was built by the Egyptian government this past November
to ward off demonstrators from nearby Tahrir Square away from the
embassy.
Romih, 41, commutes downtown from a working-class neighborhood near
the pyramids. His shop ordinarily depends on foot traffic from the
bustling business districts surrounding Tahrir Square, but now because
of an elaborate system of walls and barbed-wire roadblocks built by the
authorities, the area near the embassy has been cut off from the core of
the downtown.
As a result, he said, his business is “at zero.” By late afternoon
that day his revenue was only 20 Egyptian pounds, or a little over $3.
“People should dig tunnels like they do in Gaza,” he said, waving his
water-pipe hose at the unsightly wall.
Two of the storefronts adjacent to White House Net were gutted, Romih
said, during recent clashes between demonstrators and police. The
burned-out shell of a car still lies upside down in the road in front of
the shop. Across the street, men in business suits were hoisting
themselves over a tall iron fence in order to get home from work,
handing briefcases to one another over the top of the barrier. Armed
security men stationed at a checkpoint leading to the embassy looked on.
Because of the government’s walls, scenes like this one are the new
normal in the upscale neighborhood of Garden City and other areas south
of Tahrir Square, the epicenter of the winter 2011 uprising that ended
the 30-year dictatorship of Hosni Mubarak.
On one recent afternoon, at
the same intersection near the embassy I saw a young woman hand a pink
plastic carrier containing a fluffy white cat to a man, her husband or
fiancé, before hopping over the fence. The two then strolled, arm in
arm, cat in tow, in the direction of Tahrir.
With the second anniversary of the uprising now approaching and unrest simmering in the wake of Islamist President
Mohamed Morsi’s
November 2012 power grab, the walls have become a symbol of the
political crisis in Egypt. According to architect and urban planner Omar
Nagati, the walls are indicative of the postrevolutionary renegotiation
of the “rules of the game between the people and the authorities. The
people are setting the terms and the authorities are just responding by
building walls."
The massive policing apparatus set up by Mubarak was temporarily
paralyzed by fierce protests during the revolution, but it did not
disappear completely. Nor did the grievances that preceded the
revolution: poverty, police brutality and a lack of democracy in civic
institutions.
What has changed is Egyptians’ attitude toward authority.
The government can no longer prevent protests, even violent ones,
resorting instead to physically separating the protesters now
perpetually encamped in Tahrir Square from the government installations
and embassies to the south.
“The walls are a total evasion of dealing with the issues,” says
Mohamed Elshahed, a doctoral candidate at New York University who
studies urban planning in Cairo. “There was a stronger security
apparatus [under Mubarak] that quieted things before they turned into a
protest. Now since protests are just a matter of life — they just happen
— the walls seem to be the solution for the moment.”
There is nothing new about the use of such obstructive tactics by
governments to contain insurrection. As Elshahed points out, the French
authorities built walls in Algiers to stifle the anticolonial movement
there in the 1950s.
Israel’s separation barrier runs through the length
of the West Bank, carving through East Jerusalem, Bethlehem and other
cities. The
U.S. military
divided Baghdad with concrete blast walls. Egypt’s own government,
Elshahed observes, began using perimeter walls and metal barricades to
protect government buildings from outbursts of public anger in the late
1970s, caused in part by then President Anwar Sadat’s unpopular economic
reforms.
The 2011 uprising brought a new intensity to the struggle over public
space in Egypt. The military and security forces began building walls,
consisting of large concrete cubes reinforced with metal straps, across
streets leading to the widely hated Interior Ministry and the
headquarters of the security forces, after five days of street battles
in November 2011. A few of those walls came down over the subsequent
months, some unilaterally dismantled by the government, some torn down
by demonstrators using ropes.
But before long, new rounds of protest prompted the authorities to
build new walls, including one of the walls near the U.S. embassy, built
during the demonstrations over an anti-Islamic YouTube clip on Sept. 11
last year.
In November 2012, Muslim Brotherhood–affiliated President
Morsi issued a set of decrees giving himself sweeping powers, triggering
some of the largest demonstrations since the uprising against Mubarak.
Amid ongoing fighting between riot police and stone-throwing
demonstrators, the antigovernment forces re-established a protest camp
in Tahrir Square and the security forces rebuilt the wall across Qasr
al-Aini Street, the main boulevard leading south from the city center.
The physical separation between the revolutionary camp in Tahrir and a
sort of Green Zone around government buildings was now complete.
As a part of an ever evolving geography of protest, anti–Muslim
Brotherhood demonstrators then shifted their focus from Tahrir Square to
the presidential palace, inherited by Morsi from Mubarak, in the
suburban neighborhood of Heliopolis. The government responded by
building yet another wall outside the palace, this one cutting across a
four-lane road and a set of railroad tracks, with one narrow gap for
cars to trickle through.
The cumulative result of all this construction has been the mangling
of a portion of Cairo’s urban landscape. Cairo’s notoriously snarled
traffic has been rerouted to avoid the whole vicinity of Tahrir Square,
causing even more gridlock.
In quieter times, the walk from the elite
Garden City neighborhood (home to the U.S., British and other embassies)
to Tahrir was a five-minute stroll along Qasr al-Aini Street. Now that
same journey is as much as a mile-long trek, winding around walls,
barbed-wire roadblocks, armored security trucks and burned-out cars.
In stark contrast to the rest of Cairo’s downtown, which remains
vibrant long into the night, the streets near the Interior Ministry and
the parliament building are deserted by dusk, except for the
bored-looking, black-clad troops of the Central Security Forces, their
riot shields, helmets, and batons stacked in the middle of a street. As
Elshahed of New York University puts it, “It feels completely like a
military garrison town.”
Still, a number of pedestrians puzzling over the strangled routes in
and out of Garden City approached the obstacles with a bit of Zen. For
all their appearance of permanence, the walls and the political crisis
they represent simply cannot remain indefinitely.
Waiting in line to hop
the fence near the U.S. embassy on his way home from work last
Thursday, mechanical engineer Ahmad Baghat, 24, shrugged. “Sure, the
walls are better than the problems,” he said, referring euphemistically
to the rioting at the embassy, “but they can’t stay forever.”
Lawyer Khaled Zenhom, who stopped at the Qasr al-Aini wall on his way
home from the Saudi consulate, where he was applying for a visa, was
even more expansive. “The barriers don’t bother us,” he said. “All of
Egypt is full of doors.”
*Photo courtesy of GIANLUIGI GUERCIA / AFP / Getty Images